Introduction
Joe: Welcome back to "Very Importing People." This is a podcast about importing, customs, and trade, and is presented by USA Customs Clearance and powered by AFC International.
I am your host, customs compliance writer Joe Weaver, and our topic expert is Anthony Ambrosino, licensed customs broker.
And we're discussing what keeps customs brokers up at night. Anthony, what has got you tossing and turning these days?
We're on topic Section 338.
What is Section 338?
Anthony: So the Section 338 was the newest tariff... imposed by this administration.
I'm gonna tell you this, Joe, most importers and probably even most customs brokers have never even heard of Section 338 before this year. Now, I will say this. I want to say it was back in April. April 9th. I... literally my fourth day, fifth day here at R+L Global Logistics, AFC International, I saw a post because, as trade nerds, we kind of keep up with each other on LinkedIn, and I saw a post and said, "Section 338? What's that?"
So I had to do a little research about it, and it's this old tariff that's basically never been used before, but that... the statute still stands. And it was something that give— gives the administration broader strokes to impose this tariff— yes, he imposed it right now on Canada, and we'll get into further details about it.
You know, it just creates a brand new risk that wasn't on anybody's radar, again, overnight, that we spoke about that in the last podcast, you know, these changes just happen overnight. You know, compliance planning and supply chains that were built around the USMCA have now been... disrupted, they've been turned upside down. Importers are learning quickly that these trade agreements do not eliminate costs and risks any longer. Supply chain disruptions that happen overnight... alternative sourcing becomes critical to help that.
Now we saw that 10 years ago when the original tariffs speak began... on China... a lot of people started sourcing from Vietnam, so... you know, you might see... our importers and customers sourcing from other places than Canada.
The importers really need to monitor these executive actions more closely. You know, Section 338... you might even see this again later on, but Section 338 is now in the toolbox. It's in the trade toolbox. And I suspect that you're going to see it other places than just Canada.
I know we're going to talk about that, but I'm pretty sure... that's what I wrote in my LinkedIn post back in April. Companies need to start evaluating more, again, where they source from.
Joe: That's 100% true. Section 338... I saw it charitably referred to as "an artifact of the Smoot-Hawley era."
I remember about back in April—since my position here as a writer requires me to occasionally go, you know, digging for topics to write about—I think it was about April—I went kind of thinking like, "I wonder if there are any other, like, tariffs that he has not used yet specifically."
So I just went searching for that, and I found, buried deep in the darkest annals of the Internet, this one little scholarly post two people had written about Section 338 called "The Forgotten Tariff Authority" or something, and I thought to myself at the time, I said, "I got a feeling that's not going to get forgotten that much longer."
And it turns out I was right.
Anthony: That's right. That's exactly... when I was looking at it, you know, as a trade nerd, I was like, "Wait a minute. What is this? Section 338?" And I had to do the research, and I was like almost couldn't find anything.
Joe: It's like going through your toolbox, and, like, you try to fix something with a screwdriver, you try to fix something with a wrench, all of a sudden, down at the bottom of the toolbox is a gigantic hammer that you forgot you had. That's what we're dealing with here.
Even though this seemed, at the time, I know we talked about it when this first came out, Section 338, when it first got mentioned in the news here is that it seemed like it might have been more of, like, a leverage tactic earlier in the year, but it's not only been used to impose tariffs on Canada, but to outright ban the importation of certain goods, ranging from motorcycles to a lot of popular cheeses and liquors.
And cheeses are going to factor into this a little bit later when I talk about the news that I just read yesterday about the Court of International Trade. So that will be fun.
July 20th - White House Announcement of Section 338
Joe: But, to familiarize importers with this... kind of old tariff that is making new news, we've got a little timeline set up for you here because this one has been— the back and forth on this one has been bitter, and it's a lot to keep up with, so let's start... with July 20th: The White House announced a... 50% Section 338 tariff on certain Canadian goods. That was going to come into effect after 30 days.
You talk to that a little, Anthony.
Anthony: So that's when, I want to say, most brokers first started to say, "Okay, what is Section 338?" And they started paying attention to it.
Because, I think, prior to this announcement, Section 338 was just, like you said, referred to... or thought about—and from the Smoot-Hawley... It was just this dormant, sleeping trade statute that, you know, no one ever thought would come out. Guess what? It came out.
Many importers initially assumed, like you just mentioned, this is a negotiating thing. And it was.
All speaking, honestly, it was a negotiating... right? He wanted to put himself... the administration wanted to put themselves in a position... that it would never have to actually take effect.
Well, lo and behold, it did have to take effect.
The companies, you know, are... especially our company. We do a lot of border crossings. A highly integrated with Canada's supply chains suddenly now evaluate and look, "Hey, what are we doing here?"
We have to contemplate the compliance from this for industries that are heavily dependent on Canadian sourcing.
30 days? Man, we've got to figure this out!
It's not enough time.
August 19th - Delay for Negotiations
Joe: So then we move on to... from there, we get to August 19th, and, for a moment, it looked like there might have been some hope.
There was a delay on August 19th, three-day delay for the parties to continue negotiations. This was between the U.S. and Canada's respective trade representatives.
Importers had some hope a negotiated resolution might still be possible, but, Anthony, you can take it from there.
Anthony: Yeah, a lot of companies, they paused... They paused on their sourcing decisions because they didn't want to react to the tariff.
Again, they thought it was a negotiation, and then, with the delay, they said, "Oh, this is definitely not gonna happen." They did pause on their sourcing.
Unfortunately, the uncertainty can be just as disruptive as the tariffs themselves. And, you know... For us, that time frame, we saw a lot less border crossings, to be quite honest with you. Business did slow down, so it did disrupt. Importers are left trying to determine whether to accelerate shipments, delay shipments, and when I say "accelerate," beat the tariff. Right? "Can we beat the tariff, or just stay the course?" So it was a big disruption.
And brokers, you know, constantly fielding questions from clients about what the final outcome—and nobody knew. Nobody really knew anything. So nobody had a definitive answer.
August 22nd - Tariffs Go into Effect
Joe: We got a somewhat more definitive answer. After August 22nd, the hope that existed momentarily fell through.
The specific reasons... you can probably check out the whitehouse.gov website if you're interested in looking into the reasoning behind it, but that's not terribly important to what we're talking about here.
The tariffs came into effect.
Anthony: Yup. And once they did, the conversation's now— and the questions were all answered.
And it shifted from planning to "Okay, damage control. Now what?" Now we have to implement it.
Again, the programmers have to program, and... the brokers have to act on it. Companies have to evaluate their profitability with existing purchase orders which... already forecasted. Now they have to add this tariff to it, and, you know, especially when inventory is already in transit and things like that.
Importers are learning a hard lesson that trade agreements, including USMCA, don't shield companies from every single trade action. Okay? We saw a renewed focus on country of origin and analysis... and then supply chain diversification because companies want predictable landed costs, and you can't get predictable landed costs modeling in this climate right now.
And, you know... many importers discovered that concentrating way too much on— it's a sourcing risk for sourcing from a single country.
Joe: Especially for those impacted commodities, a lot of food, bottled alcohol, things of that nature.
Canada Retaliates
Joe: So, Canada didn't take this lying down. They are, traditionally, one of the nicer countries, but they do have some, you know, backbone, so they announced some countermeasures.
15%, 25%, and 50% tariffs... of their own on U.S. products being imported into Canada. So this is more of an export issue.
But, Anthony, you can talk about that a little bit before we talk about why it became an import issue again.
Anthony: At that point, the issue... it was a much broader... it was much broader than just an import cost. Right?
Companies that were operating on both sides of the border now had the exposure in both directions. So these retaliatory measures create challenges for manufacturers, distributors... you know, importers, and exporters that move products across the border in both directions. Especially when you have the same company in both sides of the border, you know, that are related companies. That creates problems, too.
And it increases the stress level for the brokers, as well. You know, businesses begin evaluating not only the customs cost, but also the long-term supply chain strategies.
Eventually, I guess, they figure this might go away in a couple of years, but you just never know.
This is... where the executive actions that are... in effect right now, you know, create... ripple effects... far beyond... the originally targeted products.
Import Prohibition of Canadian Commodities
Joe: And speaking of ripple effects... the federal government retaliated to Canada's retaliation.
And, now, we're no longer just dealing with tariffs. We have moved all the way into... import prohibitions.
Anthony: Yeah, so, it's difficult enough to manage, you know, tariffs... for your landed costs and your price-basing transactions. Right?
Import prohibitions or bans are completely different. It's a different challenge because there's no tariff solution. Right? You just can't import it.
Once a product becomes... prohibited, importers now have to identify alternative sourcing... I always point back to alternative sourcing and/or alternative products in alternative markets.
This is where the supply chain resiliency becomes more important than just... pure customs optimization. And companies that had these contingency plans in place were in a much stronger position than companies relying on that single supplier or country.
USMCA Preferences and Section 338 Tariffs
Joe: So one of the hard realities importers probably ran into pretty quickly: if they made the assumption that USMCA would, somehow, cancel out these very specifically Canadian tariffs... it does not.
USMCA still handles column duties for goods that fall within its guidelines, but it does nothing for Section 338.
Anthony: No, that's right. So that was a big misconception that we've encountered this year.
Like you said, Column 1, rated duty. Most-favored-nation, free.
But you're still subject to the Section 338 tariff. Importers that qualify assume that they were protected. No shot.
The USMCA primarily... like I just said, the preferential duty treatment, under Column 1, most-favored-nation, it does not automatically eliminate the duties that are imposed under these separate statutes. And especially this one, Section 338.
A product that can be fully qualified under the USMCA and still be exposed to the 338 duties, importers need to evaluate each tariff authority independently rather than just assuming one of those... compliance determinations solves everything.
Canadian Commodities Prohibited from Import
Joe: So, like we mentioned earlier, this has been used to just outright ban the importation of certain goods.
This is— trying to remember what I can remember off the top of my head, but there are motorcycles with piston engines in excess of 800 cubic centimeters, something to that effect.
A great deal of liquors that are sold in prepackaged states, so, if you're able to buy in bulk, I think that those might be, not necessarily exempt, but not as exposed to Section 338. So, like bottles and things of that nature are definitely exposed.
A lot of cheeses, and a lot of industrial machinery.
So an interesting, wide swath of certain Canadian goods here that you just can't bring into the country anymore.
Anthony: No, and I think it... there's a little bit more on that list, too.
Joe: There is.
Anthony: You know... things that are manufactured... some additional tools that can be added to the list, but, you know, most of the... trade nerds think that the tariffs, when discussing, are just straight enforcement.
But this Section 338, man, this is going into the toolbox. This is not... just going to be for, you know, Canada, but... yeah, when we got retaliated against... the administration retaliated right back. That's it.
So what's worse? A tariff or not being able to... being forbidden to import? Right? One of them's worse than the other.
I think the tariff is the lesser of two evils, but that's, you know, one man's humble opinion.
Joe: You can't even try to sell what you don't have. So if you're talking about importing for resale, or even importing to have something to make things here that you do sell, again...
Anthony: Right. That's what I was saying.
You know... Okay, look at consumption, right? But there are certain tools that... that you need here to make something else, and you can't even...
Specialty foods, I think you mentioned motorcycles... or parts of motorcycles, something like that.
Joe: Yeah. And I know going into Canada's annexes of the tariffs that they had on us more or less kind of reflects a lot of the stuff we have either tariffed or banned from them.
I, actually, went through that list pretty exhaustively for another content project I'm working on. I have half the Canadian HTS memorized right now, but it's not going to last.
[laughter]
Could More Section 338 Tariffs Take Effect?
Joe: So, you touched on this briefly, but...
You know, we've seen it used against Canada, we have seen it used to prohibit, we have seen it used to cause tariffs.
But this is not a tariff that can only be used on Canada.
Section 338 holds if—and I'll get to that later— we could see it used against other trade partners, and do you think, Anthony, that this is something that we'll see get used again in the near future probably?
Anthony: So, when I made my post four months ago, I didn't even have Canada on my radar. I just thought this was going to be the new, for argument's sake, replacement for IEEPA, replacement for Section 122. This was the one I thought was going to replace it.
Hopefully, the administration doesn't see this podcast, but it's of my opinion that this 338 is such a broad... range of scope that, yes, I do, in my humble opinion, I do think that this 338 is going to be used... it's in the toolbox. It's basically... in the trade toolbox, it's in the enforcement toolbox.
The administration, I would bet, if I was a betting man, this 338 is going to be used other than just Canada.
I think, you know, there's real lessons for the importers to take away from this situation. Not... these trade remedies or enforcements or whatever you want to call them, they're going to be here for at least a couple more years, and who knows after 2028 what happens. Right? Who knows?
Because we saw, back in 2020—2021, I'm sorry—2021, that entirely new administration did not take away the tariffs that were imposed. So these could be here for a while. So the importers need to be paying attention to all of this stuff.
And whether or not it's used again, or against whom, we don't know, but I have a funny feeling it will be.
I mean, the biggest thing... for the importers isn't just Canada. It's Section 338 in itself. It went from something nobody even heard of to something that is now a very real part of supply chain.
Once that trade tool gets off the shelf, it takes on a life of its own, especially in this administration.
Now, I'm not saying future administrations will continue to use or act with 338, but it's going to be here... for a minute.
Joe: And it might just be a minute, so...
Gellert Global Group Corp. v. Trump - Overview
Joe: What I'm going to talk about a little bit now is something that... only kind of made the news here in the last couple of days.
I'm writing about it for something else, so Anthony might not know much about this.
A company in New Jersey— Gellert Food Distributing, Fellert Food Importing, one of the two— has filed suit in the Court of International Trade against the executive administration, CBP, USTR, the usual suspects, in order to invalidate the Section 338 tariffs, and they are seeking immediate injunctive relief.
The argument is based on a few different assertions.
One, the invocation and subsequent repeal of IEEPA. Obviously, the administration tried to do this one way, the Supreme Court found that it was illegal to do it that way, the argument here being that this administration plays kind of fast and loose with tariff rules.
Another one, you know, being that, even if this Section 338 were to hold water in 2026, that, by invoking—by announcing responsive tariffs, and only giving importers something like 12 days, I think it was, to be ready for the adjustment in order to get that... be able to dial in their landed costs. The 30-day language that's in Smoot-Hawley itself was not followed.
And there is also—and this is probably going to be—the hardest thing from my... just from my own experience, I think, to prove is that their lawyers are also saying that it is impliedly invalid, Section 338, because, about four years after Smoot-Hawley was passed, these things were kind of invalidated by a new trade agreement between multiple countries, and Section 301 is intended to do what Section 338 was initially intended for.
So, if... if... this ends up in front of Judge Eaton—fingers crossed, we've seen him do some good in the past—we may see some news that could be good news for importers in the next...
Well, there's not really a date on the docket yet, but definitely keep an eye on our website because—on our Tariff Tracker, I will be staying up to date on that as much as possible.
Anthony: Absolutely. That's... I didn't know that.
Joe: So, yeah, I'll send you a link to that. You can check out our website sometime, Anthony. It'll be great.
Outro
Joe: Alright, so that's going to wrap it up for our discussion about Section 338 tariffs today.
We appreciate you taking time to listen to the "Very Importing People" podcast.
And, to keep up with new episodes every Thursday, please visit our website at USACustomsClearance.com/podcast.
We're here to get you accustomed to Customs.
Disclaimer
Voiceover: The information shared on "Very Importing People" is for general educational and informational purposes only.
Customs regulations and requirements can vary based on the specific circumstances of an import, and may change over time.
This podcast is not legal advice, and should not be relied upon as guidance for a specific transaction.
Importers remain responsible for exercising reasonable care and complying with applicable laws and regulations.
For questions about your specific shipment or importing situation, consult a qualified customs professional or legal counsel.